When I came up
with the idea or this blogpost I had a load of categories, ideas and things in
mind that I would be able to write about. However having written about three
quarters of it I then realised that most of the things I was trying to get off
my chest were so inter-related and intertwined it was hard to keep my thoughts
in my original order. I’d write one thing then realise I have already said it
somewhere else. So I’ve kind of scrapped it – as was.
When thinking
back to last year’s contest there are a few threads that connect the acts that
did well and a different thread that draws those ‘lower table’ acts. Nothing
that you will read will be a surprise or be anything new but some of these
things are thethings I feel I’d love to see (or not see) in 2018
‘Real’ Music
Real meaning real
instruments and real style.
OK as much as I
would love to see the orchestra make at Eurovision, it realistically isn’t
going to happen. But since Conchita won in 2014, the status of a fully
orchestrated backing track has gained momentum. And after the jESC winner of
2016 and ESC winner of 2017 having highly orchestrated backing , with lengthy introductions,
it feels like electronic over-production is out – proper instruments are in. I
mean Kaliopi’s “Dona” is quite the laughable sham. The faux violins makes it almost
laughable.
However if you
are going to do electronic music it also needs to be done right. If you are
going to show your guitar rock roots - do it with pride. If you have an 90’s
Britpop edge – go for it. If you are a bright young (or even tarnished old)
schlager puppet – show them what you are made of. Whatever you do it must be
done wholeheartedly. In addition one could almost extend this feeling to the
national broadcaster and the delegation. If the ‘team’ doesn’t have the energy,
belief and oooomph( as well as a bit of money) you might as well turn up in a
t-shirt haying ‘We’re going to lose!”
If there is one
thing we’ve learnt about modern Eurovision – safe doesn’t work. Middle of the
road might as well be ‘bottom of the scoreboard’. Being a Marmite act/song is
no bad thing. Having a loyal, niche audience that really loves your song is
much better than everybody saying ‘it’s ok’. The latter will never extrapolate
into votes.
National Sounds
Although Salvador
won in 2017 and it is easy just to contrue this into ‘Europe likes languages’
there is a slightly bigger thing going on here. Looking back at previous
Eurovision’s the number of fully or partly non-English songs has been
dwindling. But when done right, this small proportion of entries has been punching
above its weight e.g. Il Volo in 2015, Zoe and Amir in 2016 (even though it
pains me to say it as I have no idea why these did so well in the first play
but hey ho!)
Although not my
favoured form of selection, internal selections can offer more edgy entries. It
also gives the selected act a free reign to do something in their style and be more true to their artistic selves.This system may also entice bigger starts into the mix. I am hoping that
in this coming Eurovision season we see national finals with more languages and
also more national styles. Although I am not the biggest fan of Balkan ballads
they have been lacking in stature and power of late and the Swedification of
entries (I’m looking at you Cyprus, Georgia and Azerbaijan in particular!) has
started to irk me. I don’t necessarily want every Greek entry to contain a
bouzouki or every Russian song to start with a balalaika intro or any Nordic
entry to allude to the nyckelharpa. I do, however want to feel like I am listening
to a new story, a new place, a new point of view.
In other words
Jon Henrik please be third time lucky !!!!!
Less is More
Although it has
kind of sneaked up on us all without noticing, there is a real trend of
(almost) solo singers winning Eurovision of late. Conchita and Salvador won
with no backing singers, Mans and Jamala had hidden backing singers but had a
busy backdrop while even Loreen’s sparce performance had hidden backing singers
and the help of one dancer.
To open this
further it seems that uber-theatrical pyros, superfluous backing
singers/dancers and over-cinemantic backdrops are now blasé. In a classic case
Joci Papai’s dancer/violinist combo seemed to strike a chord as both helped to
emphasise the story and the use of ‘ethnic’ instrumentation throughout the
song. Blanche’s simple yet vulnerable staging but with very clever camerawork,
justifiably won over the hearts of Europe But Demy’s confusing staging (and
slightly over salacious dancers) AND Anja’s overblown use of pryos during the
last minute probably left most people thinking ‘It looks like they think
they’ve already won’. No-one likes a cocky smart arse.
Although I enjoy the spectacle of teh light shows and video screens, I sometimes wish they'd get way from it. I think aEurovision song and staging should not just be able on its present stage but if it works on the 1987 stage too then even better.
This all said and
done, what I am trying to say is don’t try too hard and don’t add too much. You
are selling a SONG. Of you try too hard you will end up selling running
travelators or Hawaiian shirts instead
Diversity ✔ Individuality ✔ … Family?
It’s always nice
when a country gets its first win but it’s also nice when a new language or a
different style of song/singer wins. This year we had a couple of firsts in
“Amar Pelos Dois” First win for Portugal in Portuguese and writer, Luisa, being
the very first woman to be credited as a sole writer and composer of a winning
song.
In all seriousness
– where have Mr and Mrs Sobral been hiding these two???
Are there any
more children to come out of the woodwork for the double win?!?!
Surprise aside,
do we need to see more of ‘the family’? Looking back over Eurovision history
there haven’t been many Eurovision winners nay entries written and performed by
family members (by this I don’t mean married couples I am thinking more blood
relatives) OG3NE’s entry was written by their father and you could tell that
the song and the whole experience meant a lot to them. Francesco’s brother had
a composing credit on “Occidentali’s Karma’.
I think that this also links back to having a tight team. Seriously how
many of the other delegations could have the songwriter sang the songs for the
actual singer during rehearsals…? Or
maybe rehearsals are overrated. Maybe rehearsals are for sissies.
For everyone like
me who was over the moon Salvador won and that Joci rocked the televoting and
that Francesco got a reasonable finishing place (although he was my fave there
was never any way he was going to win) there will be someone else distraught at
the result. I just hope that this coming Eurovision brings lots of different
things but most of all that all the entries have a string of truth, passion, encourangement
and heart that runs through it, its singer, its team… all the way back to the
country of origin.